iSixSigma Homepage
Blogosphere Homepage
iSixSigma Live!
iSixSigma Publications

Free Weekly Newsletter


Your Privacy Matters
Newsletter Archives



BLOGGERS
 
Michael Marx's [287RSS Michael Marx's Biography SixSigmaCompanies.com
Gary P. Cox [93]  RSS  Gary P. Cox's Biography
Gianna Clark [87]  RSS  Gianna Clark's Biography
Michael Cyger [77]  RSS  Michael Cyger's Biography
Sue Kozlowski [63]  RSS  Sue Kozlowski's Biography
Robin Barnwell [49]  RSS  Robin Barnwell's Biography
Andrew Downard [34]  RSS  Andrew Downard's Biography
Stephen C. Crate [20]  RSS  Stephen C. Crate's Biography
Sven Saerens [19]  RSS  Sven Saerens's Biography
Holly Hawkins [19]  RSS  Holly Hawkins's Biography
Charles McKinney [14]  RSS  Charles McKinney's Biography
Laura Gibbons [13]  RSS  Laura Gibbons's Biography
Capt. Harris [12]  RSS  Capt. Harris's Biography
J P Spencer [12]  RSS  J P Spencer's Biography
Vincent Chin [9]  RSS  Vincent Chin's Biography
James Considine [9]  RSS  James Considine's Biography
Zakir Ahamed [3]  RSS  Zakir Ahamed's Biography


CATEGORIES
 
Book Review [3]  RSS
Buzz/Press [57]  RSS
Conferences [59]  RSS
General [294]  RSS
Government [18]  RSS
Guest Blog [12]  RSS
History [10]  RSS
Innovation [16]  RSS
Leadership [140]  RSS
Lean [21]  RSS
Management [153]  RSS
Methodology [148]  RSS
Podcasts [8]  RSS
Research [20]  RSS
The Cox-Box [92]  RSS


RECENT ENTRIES RSS
 
Decoys by Gary P. Cox
Innovation and Six Sigma by Andrew Downard
Six Sigma - IAGTM by Gianna Clark
iSixSigma Live Seattle by Michael Cyger
Six Sigma Hat by Gary P. Cox
The Consultant Within by Andrew Downard
More Henry Ford by Stephen C. Crate


LATEST COMMENTS
 
Innovation and Six Sigma
by : cheryl howard
iSixSigma Live Seattle
by : Stephen C. Crate
iSixSigma Live Seattle
by : Meikah Delid
iSixSigma Live Seattle
by : K. North-Miller
 


CTQ MEDIA BLOGS
 
Sourcingmag Blogosphere

BPM Enterprise Blogosphere

RealInnovation Commentary
 


SIX SIGMA BLOGS
 
Today's Six Sigma

Lean Six Sigma Academy

Leadership & Business

Six Sigma for Corporate Real Estate

Keith Bower Podcasts
 


LEAN BLOGS
 
Lean Blog

Got Boondoggle?

Evolving Excellence

Reforming Project Management

Learning About Lean
 


BUSINESS BLOGS
 
shmula

Seth Godin's Blog

Decker Marketing

Guy Kawasaki

Fast Company Now
 


BLOG ARCHIVE RSS
 



RETIRED BLOGGERS
 
Kosta Chingas

Gary Cone

Brian Costello

Andrew Hillig

Rick Maher

Lisa Moore
 


SigmaXL V5.1 Excel Add-In
Six Sigma Statistics & Graphics. Ideal for training. Now compatible with Excel 2007. Free Trial.
www.SigmaXL.com
 
Voice of the Customer
AMS can help you find out what your customers really want!
www.ams-inc.com
 
6s & Small Co's
How one company went from 2 to 201 employees in 3 years, and why they now use 6s. Exclusively in iSixSigma Magazine!
www.isixsigma-magazine.com
 
6s Projects and Presentations
Immediately purchase and download Six Sigma project examples, research and training tools.
store.isixsigma.com
 
6s Recruiting
We can help you staff your org, in weeks! Call us at 847-919-0922 x8857 to get started.
jobs.isixsigma.com/
 

24 April 2008 by Michael Marx
Printable version  |  Email to a friend

Project Failure: Eight Reasons by Minitab

Yesterday, I attended a Minitab Webinar showcasing the top 8 reasons Six Sigma projects fail. Presented by Lou Johnson & Cate Twohill. Lou took care of the project failure segment (which was the vast majority) and Cate talked a bit about Minitab’s Quality Companion.

First off they did a fantastic job. Lou’s history and experience with Six Sigma and statistics coupled with his passion for getting to the bottom of project failure…resulted in this fine presentation.

The data was based off a survey of nearly 150 of Minitab’s customers at nearly 100 different companies. And yes there were more than eight reasons for failure cited by respondents. There were actually 42 reasons, but the top eight represented 62 percent of the total.

Lou laid out the eight reasons with detailed explanations and examples for each reason. I won’t go in to any detail besides listing them as Lou is sure to give this presentation again and again…

The Top Eight Reasons Six Sigma Projects Fail...

# 8 - The project solution was not implemented
# 7 - Project scope too big
# 6 - Not enough training
# 5 - Project too small for DMAIC rigor
# 4 - Project forced into DMAIC
# 3 - Project had no data or bad data
# 2 - Project not linked to Finances

and the #1 reason Six Sigma projects fail...
No management support

The biggest takeaway was, as Lou described it, “Rule #1: Pick the right project.” Four of the top eight reasons can be attributed to project selection (now comes my favorite part of the presentation, the iSixSigma research quote):

“While only 32% of respondents in organizations with new (less than one year) Six Sigma programs frequently or always use a formal prioritization process, 63% percent of those in organizations with five to ten years experience with Six Sigma do.” iSixSigma Magazine, March/April 2005

Throughout the presentation Lou offered a simple solution to each of the failure modes, and in most cases the solution could be found utilizing one of the features of Minitab’s Quality Companion.

Thank you Minitab for sharing these findings. Below are some additional articles from iSixSigma about project failure. As you read them you will find that they support Minitab’s findings as well as offer a few other failure modes to consider.

Tips and Suggestions for Six Sigma Project Success by Simon Bodie

Why Projects Fail by Holly Hawkins

How to Face Failed 6 Sigma Projects iSixSigma Discussion Forum

Understanding Six Sigma Deployment Failures by Mike Carnell

Project Selection Research by Jonathan Atwood, iSixSigma Magazine, March/April 2005

Save, Share & Recommend This Blog
Digg It Digg It Del.icio.us Del.icio.us Reddit Reddit Google Google

Yahoo! Yahoo

StumbleUpon StumbleUpon
Buzz/Press , Management , Methodology , Research
posted by Michael Marx  at  12:29 PM ET | comments [2]


BLOG COMMENT

posted by  Ian Furst  [ http://www.waittimes.blogspot.com ] 24 April 2008 at 2:18 PM ET
I've posted before on it here but in healthcare (and I assume it extends elsewhere) projects have to increase profit/efficiency and decrease workload. If they only do one or the other they usually have an uphill battle. I'm intrested by the management support issue -- it's easy to say it but why wouldn't management support something? I'm sure there are all kinds of political reasons but as long as it meets the above two goals it should be easy assuming implementation is not too difficult. Sounds like a good seminar.

www.waittimes.blogspot.com www.waittimes.blogspot.com
 


posted by  Cate Twohill  [ http://www.minitab.com ] 9 May 2008 at 12:44 PM ET
Michael, thanks for the kind words.

We had such a great turnout for the Top 8 Reasons Six Sigma Projects Fail webinar in April we've decided to schedule it again.

Tuesday, June 17th at 11am ET. Anyone can register by clicking here.

Thanks much!

Cate Twohill
Product Marketing Manager
Minitab Inc.
 

ADD COMMENT
(*) indicates required fields
author (*) :
email address :
url :
 
  bold italic underline add hyperlink add email hyperlink centre unorder list order list add image quote emoticon smiles
 
comment (*) :

max characters : 2100

characters remaining :
remember me :